The Front Page: SCOOPED Reviewed by Jo-Anne Bishop

By Jo-Anne Bishop, The Beat Magazine 2025

The Palace Theatre opened its 2025–2026 season last night with a bold, gender-bending adaptation of the 1928 classic The Front Page, written by Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur. Set in the 1920s, the play unfolds in the press room of Chicago’s Criminal Courts Building, which overlooks the gallows at Cook County Jail where an execution is scheduled for the following day.

Director Dinah Watts spent months reshaping the piece, removing offensive language, cutting certain characters, and casting women in the traditionally male roles. The result, The Front Page: Scooped, is a slightly gentler interpretation of what Watts has called a “dated, offensive” and “terrible, old play.”

On the technical side, the production shone brightly. David Long’s set design, brought to life by Heather Meadows and her crew, captured the messy, frenetic spirit of a 1920s newsroom with papers scattered, shelves disorganized, and period-appropriate furnishings. Costumes reflected the era well, even if a few fits felt off, while lighting and sound provided a consistent sense of atmosphere and polish.

*(Pictured: The Cast & Crew of The FrontPage: SCOOPED. Photo by Ross Davidson)*

The performances themselves offered a mix of strengths and challenges. The play’s hallmark rapid-fire dialogue sometimes tipped into an overly frantic pace, making it harder for the audience to catch every clever line. At times, the energy felt more like shouting than sharp wit, which dulled some of the humor. With just a touch more pacing and clarity, the comedy might have landed with even greater impact.

*(Pictured: Peggy (Mara Fraccaro) and Hildy (Danika Tipping) Photo by Ross Davidson)*

That said, there were many highlights. Danika Tipping (Hildy), Sarah Rice (Endicott), Lisa Eastick (Murphy), Judy Cormier (Pincus), and Martha Zimmerman Ross (Walter) each delivered memorable turns. David O’Garr provided delightful comic relief as “Mother”/Mrs. Grant, while Catharine Sullivan offered a standout performance as Mollie Malloy—authentic, layered, and engaging. At times, the ensemble’s choice to lean into exaggerated mannerisms when portraying male characters distracted from the storytelling, but the commitment to character was never in question.

*(Pictured: Louie (Chandie East) addresses the Press Room reporters. Photo by Ross Davidson)*

The two acts also carried different energies. The first flew by in a blur of chaos, leaving little time to fully connect with the characters. The second act found a steadier rhythm, allowing the humor to breathe and the performances to shine more naturally. Still, the play’s darker themes—corruption in politics, the media, and the looming execution—are a tricky fit for comedy, even in a reworked form. Ultimately, The Front Page: Scooped was a production full of ambition and craft. Its technical achievements were undeniable, and while its delivery sometimes felt overwhelming, the cast’s dedication and the creative vision behind the adaptation gave the audience plenty to reflect on. Add in the Palace’s welcoming touches—a live jazz ensemble in Procunier Hall before the show, a signature cocktail at intermission, and the theatre’s warm atmosphere—and the evening made for a memorable start to the season