Steel Magnolias Hits Like a Hammer
By Jo-Anne Bishop
“I would rather have 30 minutes of wonderful than a lifetime of nothing special.” – Shelby Eatenton-Latcherie, in Robert Harling’s Steel Magnolias
The Elgin Theatre Guild’s production of Steel Magnolias in St. Thomas delivers two and a half hours of something truly special.
Set in Truvy Jones’ beauty salon in small-town Louisiana during the 1980s—where secrets, gossip, and the occasional sweet treats are shared—Steel Magnolias is a story of unwavering bonds and enduring friendship. The set, though simple, radiates authenticity and rustic charm, immersing the audience so completely that it feels as though we are peering through the salon’s mirror where its patrons peer back at us.
A great theatre experience should educate, entertain, and inspire, guiding the audience through a journey of emotions. This production does exactly that—moving effortlessly from heartwarming laughter among friends to moments of fear, loss, and grief. It is performed with such conviction that one almost forgets they are sitting in a small theatre in downtown St. Thomas.
(Steel Magnolias Set. Photo Credit: Ross Davidson)
A Director’s Vision, A Cast’s Strength
Much credit goes to director Cindi Armer Almeida, who assembled a strong ensemble capable of carrying the weight of such a beloved play turned feature film. Each woman brings her own distinctive energy and colourful take on the characters to the role.
- Susan Williams perfectly embodies Clairee Belcher, the quintessential Southern lady of society.
- Sile Ferguson is endearing as the shy and slightly insecure newcomer, Annelle Dupuy-DeSoto.
- Kim Braine-Ott delights as the sharp-tongued yet lovable Ouiser Boudreaux—a role performed with just the right mix of bite and heart.
Their performances provide a rich foundation that ensures the story never falters.
The three leads, however, are the true standouts of this production.
- Sarah Abbot-Taylor brings Truvy to life with warmth, wit, and charm. Her facial expressions, movements, and just that absolute feeling of authenticity transport us straight to the bayou.
- Makayla Ashenden’s Shelby is magnetic—delicate yet strong, embodying the duality of steel and magnolia with such a beauty and grace, you are completely drawn into her character.
- Sam Sabathy gives a breathtaking performance as M’Lynn. Her emotional journey ebbs, flows, and then crescendos into a devastating second act that leaves the audience in tears. It was, quite simply, phenomenal. A word I don’t use lightly.
(Pictured: Cast and Crew of Steel Magnolias. Photo Credit: Ross Davidson)
Rarely have I seen a community theatre performance stir such a genuine emotional reaction from an audience. The believability of these performances and cohesiveness of the cast is what makes it a bona fide success.
In her Director’s Notes, Almeida writes, “It’s the perfect play to see right now given the climate of today’s headlines.” Indeed, the production resonates as a timely reminder of the healing power of laughter, love, and friendship. The need for connection is universal, and this play underscores it with compassion and truth.
Prepare to be moved. Bring your friends, family, and loved ones to Truvy’s beauty parlour, and allow yourself to be immersed in the lives of these six remarkable women. You’ll leave with a renewed appreciation for the strength of friendship and the beauty of human connection.
Bravo to the cast, crew, and director. May this production enjoy an excellent run.
If you go:
ELGIN THEATRE GUILD – Home
Where – Princess Avenue Playhouse, 40 Princess Avenue, St Thomas
Tickets: $25 plus fees
When – September 18th – 28th, 2025
Reviewed by Jo-Anne Bishop
The Beat Magazine 2025 