Reviewed by Ian Gifford

It’s December in Canada, and Mother Nature has already announced in no uncertain terms that she intends for this one to be a white Christmas. This also means the ubiquitous Christmas albums will be hitting shelves and streaming platforms with more of the same old carols that you’ve been hearing since you were a little kid, without much variation in the sound. London, Ontario’s Maggie’s Wake have made a statement of their own with the release of Close to Home, a seven-song holiday-themed EP, with three never-before-heard, original Christmas tunes.
Maggie’s Wake is a bit of a super group, (forgive me if you’ve read me saying that once or twice before), including two of Canada’s finest fiddle players in Tara Dunphy (The Rizdales and solo) and Lindsay Schindler (Rant Maggie Rant and Trent Severn) rounded out by the rhythm section of Andrew Kosty on upright bass and Kenneth Palmer on guitar. Kenneth was also the EP’s engineer/mixer with production by Tara and Lindsay.

(Pictured: Maggie’s Wake.)
The seven songs include a gorgeous cover of Gordon Lightfoot’s “Song For A Winter’s Night”, a handful of traditional/original Christmas/winter songs arranged for fiddles, guitar, and bass, as well as flute and tin whistle by Tara, plus three original Christmas songs written by Tara Dunphy. If you have not been exposed to the music of Maggie’s Wake thus far, you should know that these are four serious players! Their chemistry as a band is highly evident within the first notes of the warmly endearing “Ontario”. It’s a song that describes some of the best parts of being an Ontarian, like making snow angels and coming in to hot chocolate and maybe a “mini sticks” game in the basement or maybe a proper game of shinny when dad gets the frozen pond lit up.
“It’s dark before dinner but now we can play, I’m Wendell Clark and you’re Gilmour today!” – from “Ontario” by Tara Dunphy.
The beauty of Maggie’s Wake is their ability to jump around genres from traditional Celtic sounds to country, folk, and jazz. The latter is evident in the second Tara penned piece, “It ain’t Christmas without You” which sounds like it would be right at home on a Stéphane Grapelli album with its bouncy blend of Hot Club Jazz and Western swing vibes. The Line “they can deck the halls and trim the tree, but I’ll tell Santa when I’m on his knee, that it ain’t Christmas without you” is typical of the playful and clever lyricism that a veteran songwriter like Dunphy is capable of, as evident in the darkly romantic pieces she has written for her Honky Tonk band, The Rizdales.

(Pictured: The Rizdales. Photo by Paul Latorre.)
Interwoven throughout the EP are traditional song sets expertly arranged by Lindsay Schindler and the fellas, and they have that same sort of playful feel as opposed to old recordings of pieces like “God Rest Ye Merry Gentleman”, “The First Noel”, or “Oh Holy Night” that can often come off as staid and stuffy. The quality of the musicianship within this ensemble cannot be overstated! Two of the instrumental pieces were written by Lindsay Schindler, “Into the Shadows”
which is part of the “God Rest Ye…” set, and the beautiful title piece, “Close to Home”.
Listen to “Close to Home” https://youtu.be/yyd_1BDPbJ8?si=uEH5qOfY14wE4HtB
Rounding out the seven-song effort is another Tara Dunphy original, “Christmas is Coming (for you!)” which is probably one of the sweetest, yet cheerfully cynical new Christmas songs I’ve heard in many decades. It describes the stresses of the holiday season as being a holiday hyped by marketing execs and gives a nod to Christmas Music and decorations coming out before Hallowe’en has even passed. Like all the classic stories of the “bah humbug” attitudes of the protagonist, this song resolves into the realization that what it’s all really for is that moment when you get to step back and see that it was all about your love of family and friends and community.
Throughout the album, Tara sings naturally and almost effortlessly with a very controlled and clear voice. I’d hate to embarrass her by stating this, but she almost reminds me of Anne Murray in that she can take a song in any genre and make it her own, just from the distinctiveness of her voice. Don’t get me wrong on that; she sounds 100% like Tara Dunphy, and when blended with Lindsay’s rock-solid harmonies, this album has some of the finest singing this country has ever produced. There is a pretty good reason why they were bestowed with the Canadian Folk Music Award for Best New/Emerging artists in 2025.
This is my first real exposure to Maggie’s Wake, other than some YouTube videos and such that I have seen posted online. To say I am in awe of their talents is a huge understatement. Everything about this group and this release is very refreshing and somewhat wholesome, and is music you can share amongst friends and family, and also music that I hope reaches the ears of folks right across this vast country of ours. These pieces have what it takes to stand the test of time, so I encourage you to follow the links and check it out for yourself.
I have to give this 5 out of 5 snowflakes!
To learn more about Maggie’s Wake, visit https://www.maggieswake.com/
Follow Maggie’s Wake on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/maggieswake and Instagram https://www.instagram.com/maggieswake/
Please check out their Patreon-style page, where they are trying to raise funds for a trip to Ireland for the whole group, for a showcase in Belfast in the Spring of 2026. This is a chance for this hidden Canadian gem to gain exposure throughout the world!
https://buymeacoffee.com/maggieswake
Reviewed by Ian Gifford






























































